1.2 What do you make of the challenge set up for Portia by her father? Can he be criticized for devising such a stratagem? Can he be lauded for doing so?

1.3 In this scene, Shylock gives some indication of his dislike of Christians, Antonio in particular. Is he justified?

2.1 How does Shakespeare address the issue of race in this scene? Think about both Morocco’s words and Portia’s words.

2.2 - 2.5 What evidence in these scenes helps us to better understand Shylock?

2.7 In light of 1.2 and 2.1, why is this scene particularly ironic?

3.1 Provide a thoughtful comment on Shylock’s famous speech.

3.3 Why, according to Antonio, must the Duke side with Shylock? Does the welfare of one man trump the financial/ health of the state?

4.1 Do you think Shylock’s desire for vengeance is justified? Why or why not?

4.1 Comment on Balthazar’s (Portia’s) speech about mercy.

4.1 The treatment of Shylock is justified. Do you agree or disagree and why?

5.1 What were Portia and Nerissa trying to prove with the rings?

Any final comments?